Exosome (a very large system)

An exosome, an extracellular vesicle of 51 nm, with all atoms: an asymmetric lipid bilayer crossed by 80 copies of the tetraspanins CD81 and CD9, 8 complexes of Argonaute-2 with a microRNA and 2 nucleosomes inside, and water and NaCl (0.15 mol/L) inside and outside, in a truncated octahedron periodic cell with 580 Å between opposite hexagonal faces. The system has 13.6 million atoms and 3.6 million molecules. It is packed in two steps: first the proteins, then the lipids, the water and the ions around them.

Exosome

The exosome with a quarter cut out: the tetraspanins (blue) crossing the bilayer (orange), the Argonaute-2 complexes and the nucleosomes in the lumen (green, with their nucleic acids in yellow), water (light blue), and sodium (red) and chloride (pink) ions. The water outside is shown only behind the exosome.

The files are the packmol_exosome set of MolSimTestFiles: download and extract packmol_exosome.tar.gz (1 MB), which contains the two input files, proteins.inp and exosome.inp, and the structures, as mmCIF files: cd81.cif and cd9.cif (the tetraspanins), ago2_mirna.cif (the complex of Argonaute-2 with a microRNA), nucleosome.cif, popc.cif, pope.cif, pops.cif and dppc.cif (the lipids), water.cif, sodium.cif and chloride.cif.

The system

  • The proteins. CD81 (OPM 5TCX) and CD9 (OPM 6K4J), Argonaute-2 with a microRNA (PDB 4W5N) and the nucleosome (PDB 1KX5), with hydrogens. Preparing the structures of the proteins (adding missing atoms and hydrogens, for example with PDBFixer) is not a task of Packmol. The tetraspanins are in the frame of the OPM database: the normal of the membrane along z, the middle of the membrane at z = 0, and the extracellular side at z > 0.
  • The lipids. The membrane is asymmetric, as the plasma membrane from which exosomes bud: the outer leaflet has POPC and DPPC (standing for sphingomyelin), 2:1, and the inner one POPE, POPS and POPC, 2:1:1. The lipids are the built-in lipids of Packmol.jl (see Packmol.builtin_lipid), oriented as in the Nanoliposomes tutorial: the head atom in a band, the ends of the chains within 6 Å of the middle of the bilayer, at 228 Å from the center. The number of lipids of each leaflet is that of the most crowded surface of the leaflet, plus 10%, minus the cross-sections of the proteins in the leaflet (see Packmol.cross_section): 10,037 lipids outside and 8,111 inside.
  • Water and ions. Water at 1 g/mL in the volumes left inside and outside the vesicle, NaCl at 0.15 mol/L, and counterions for the charges of the contents of the lumen and of the POPS (inside) and of the tetraspanins (outside).

The numbers of molecules were computed, and the input files written, by a script of the repository of Packmol.jl, dev/tutorials/exosome.jl.

The regions, as distances from the center of the vesicle:

ComponentRegion (Å)
TetraspaninsCα atoms 18 to 24 Å from the middle of the membrane: outside 245 (extracellular side), inside 211 (intracellular side)
Argonaute-2 complexes and nucleosomesbelow 191.7
Inner leaflet (POPE, POPS, POPC)head atom below 200, ends of the chains above 222
Outer leaflet (POPC, DPPC)ends of the chains below 234, head atom above 256
Water and ions insidebelow 196.7
Water and ions outsideabove 258.1, up to the faces of the periodic cell

Step 1: the proteins

The proteins are packed first, alone, and then fixed in the packing of the rest of the system. Large molecules that are not part of a continuous phase are best packed this way: packed together with the water, they start overlapping it, and the water trapped inside them is slow to leave.

The tetraspanins are oriented across the membrane as the lipids are, by constraints on some of their atoms: the Cα atoms 18 to 24 Å from the middle of the membrane, on the extracellular side, outside a sphere 17 Å beyond the middle of the membrane, and those on the intracellular side inside a sphere 17 Å within it. The proteins then cross the membrane, with the extracellular side outwards, tilted by 10° on average. The indices of these atoms were taken from the coordinates of the structures in the OPM frame.

The input file proteins.inp (click to expand)
#
# The proteins of the exosome: 40 copies of each of the tetraspanins CD81 and CD9,
# crossing the membrane (the middle of the membrane at 228.0 Å from the center), and,
# in the lumen, 8 complexes of Argonaute-2 with a miRNA and 2 nucleosomes. The output
# is fixed in the packing of the exosome (exosome.inp).
#
tolerance 2.0
output proteins.cif

# To write only the initial placement of the molecules to the output file,
# without packing them (to check the constraints), uncomment the line below.

# check_initial_placement

# The tetraspanins: the Cα atoms 18 to 24 Å from the middle of the membrane on the
# extracellular side (first atoms block) outside, and on the intracellular side (second
# atoms block) inside
structure cd81.cif
  number 40
  atoms 574 588 608 629 645 1410 1426 1440 1474 1491 1510 1554 1830 1844 1858 1868 1890 1900 1916 1932 1954 1968 1988 2005 2020 2034 2053 2342 2357 2660 2679 2699 2710 2717
    outside sphere 0. 0. 0. 245.0
  end atoms
  atoms 30 52 3159 3170 3177
    inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 211.0
  end atoms
end structure

structure cd9.cif
  number 40
  atoms 621 633 661 675 697 708 727 747 808 875 886 906 927 1740 1757 1791 1806 1863 1878 1926 2175 2231 2246 2301 2311 2347 2368 2378 2853 2869 2901 2915 2937
    outside sphere 0. 0. 0. 245.0
  end atoms
  atoms 21 36 52 74 81 88 3335 3346 3356 3375
    inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 211.0
  end atoms
end structure

# The lumen
structure ago2_mirna.cif
  number 8
  inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 191.7
end structure

structure nucleosome.cif
  number 2
  inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 191.7
end structure

packmol proteins.inp

This takes about 8 seconds with 14 threads, and writes the proteins to proteins.cif.

Distributing proteins evenly

Packmol places the proteins at random positions satisfying the constraints, not evenly over the surface. To distribute them evenly (for example, on the points of a Fibonacci lattice of the sphere), write a short script that places them, and fix its output in the packing of the rest of the system. An AI agent can write such a script for the surface of your system (see Using your AI agent).

Step 2: the lipids, the water and the ions

The output of the first step is fixed (fixed 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. keeps the coordinates of the file):

The input file exosome.inp (click to expand)
#
# An exosome: an extracellular vesicle of 51 nm, with 40 copies of each of the
# tetraspanins CD81 and CD9 in an asymmetric bilayer, 8 complexes of Argonaute-2 with
# a miRNA and 2 nucleosomes inside, and water and NaCl (0.15 mol/L) inside and outside,
# in a truncated octahedron. All atoms, written as mmCIF.
#
tolerance 2.0
output exosome.cif
pbc octahedral 0. 0. 0. 580.0
periodic_boundary_style octahedral

# To write only the initial placement of the molecules to the output file,
# without packing them (to check the constraints), uncomment the line below.

# check_initial_placement

# The proteins, packed by proteins.inp, fixed
structure proteins.cif
  number 1
  fixed 0. 0. 0. 0. 0. 0.
end structure

# Inner leaflet: POPE
structure pope.cif
  number 4055
  atoms 1
    inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 199.7
  end atoms
  atoms 79 122
    outside sphere 0. 0. 0. 222.0
  end atoms
end structure

# Inner leaflet: POPS
structure pops.cif
  number 2028
  atoms 1
    inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 200.1
  end atoms
  atoms 81 124
    outside sphere 0. 0. 0. 222.0
  end atoms
end structure

# Inner leaflet: POPC
structure popc.cif
  number 2028
  atoms 1
    inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 199.9
  end atoms
  atoms 88 131
    outside sphere 0. 0. 0. 222.0
  end atoms
end structure

# Outer leaflet: POPC
structure popc.cif
  number 6691
  atoms 88 131
    inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 234.0
  end atoms
  atoms 1
    outside sphere 0. 0. 0. 256.1
  end atoms
end structure

# Outer leaflet: DPPC
structure dppc.cif
  number 3346
  atoms 84 127
    inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 234.0
  end atoms
  atoms 1
    outside sphere 0. 0. 0. 255.8
  end atoms
end structure

# The lumen: water and ions
structure water.cif
  number 1008127
  inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 196.7
end structure

structure sodium.cif
  number 4955
  inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 196.7
end structure

structure chloride.cif
  number 2747
  inside sphere 0. 0. 0. 196.7
end structure

# Outside: water and ions
structure water.cif
  number 2583306
  outside sphere 0. 0. 0. 258.1
end structure

structure sodium.cif
  number 7065
  outside sphere 0. 0. 0. 258.1
end structure

structure chloride.cif
  number 7025
  outside sphere 0. 0. 0. 258.1
end structure

First check the initial placement: uncomment the check_initial_placement line of the input file, and run it (see Checking the initial placement):

packmol exosome.inp

This takes 2.5 minutes with 14 threads, and 15 GB of memory. The initial approximation, cut as the image above, shows every component in its region:

Initial approximation

The initial approximation: the molecules are in their regions, but overlap.

Then comment the line again, and run the packing:

packmol exosome.inp

The packing converged in 65 loops, which took 33 minutes with 14 threads, using 24 GB of memory. Writing the output, a 3.5 GB mmCIF file, takes about a minute of that.

Very large systems
  • Check the initial placement first: mistakes in the constraints of a system of this size are expensive to find after the packing.
  • Use mmCIF files (.cif): the PDB format cannot number more than 99,999 atoms or 9,999 residues.
  • writeout sets the minimum time between the writes of the best solution during the packing (60 s by default): writing a file of this size takes longer than a packing loop.

Julia script

The same two steps in Julia:

using Packmolorigin = [0., 0., 0.]# Step 1: the proteins. The tetraspanins are oriented by the Cα atoms# 18 to 24 Å from the middle of the membrane, on the extracellular and# the intracellular sidestetraspanin(file, extracellular, intracellular) = structure_type(file;    number = 40,    atom_constraints = [        extracellular => OutsideSphere(origin, 245.),        intracellular => InsideSphere(origin, 211.),    ])lumen = [InsideSphere(origin, 191.7)]proteins = PackmolSystem([        tetraspanin("cd81.cif",            [574, 588, 608, 629, 645, 1410, 1426, 1440, 1474, 1491, 1510,             1554, 1830, 1844, 1858, 1868, 1890, 1900, 1916, 1932, 1954,             1968, 1988, 2005, 2020, 2034, 2053, 2342, 2357, 2660, 2679,             2699, 2710, 2717],            [30, 52, 3159, 3170, 3177]),        tetraspanin("cd9.cif",            [621, 633, 661, 675, 697, 708, 727, 747, 808, 875, 886, 906,             927, 1740, 1757, 1791, 1806, 1863, 1878, 1926, 2175, 2231,             2246, 2301, 2311, 2347, 2368, 2378, 2853, 2869, 2901, 2915,             2937],            [21, 36, 52, 74, 81, 88, 3335, 3346, 3356, 3375]),        structure_type("ago2_mirna.cif"; number = 8, constraints = lumen),        structure_type("nucleosome.cif"; number = 2, constraints = lumen),    ];    output = "proteins.cif",    tolerance = 2.0,)packmol(proteins)# Step 2: the lipids, the water and the ions, around the proteins, fixedfixed_proteins = structure_type("proteins.cif";    number = 1,    fixed = ([0., 0., 0.], [0., 0., 0.]),)# The lipids of a leaflet: the head (atom 1) and the ends of the two chainsinner(file, number, head, chain_ends) = structure_type(file; number,    atom_constraints = [        [1] => InsideSphere(origin, head),        chain_ends => OutsideSphere(origin, 222.),    ])outer(file, number, head, chain_ends) = structure_type(file; number,    atom_constraints = [        chain_ends => InsideSphere(origin, 234.),        [1] => OutsideSphere(origin, head),    ])lipids = [    inner("pope.cif", 4055, 199.7, [79, 122]),    inner("pops.cif", 2028, 200.1, [81, 124]),    inner("popc.cif", 2028, 199.9, [88, 131]),    outer("popc.cif", 6691, 256.1, [88, 131]),    outer("dppc.cif", 3346, 255.8, [84, 127]),]inside = [InsideSphere(origin, 196.7)]outside = [OutsideSphere(origin, 258.1)]solvent = [    structure_type("water.cif"; number = 1008127, constraints = inside),    structure_type("sodium.cif"; number = 4955, constraints = inside),    structure_type("chloride.cif"; number = 2747, constraints = inside),    structure_type("water.cif"; number = 2583306, constraints = outside),    structure_type("sodium.cif"; number = 7065, constraints = outside),    structure_type("chloride.cif"; number = 7025, constraints = outside),]system = PackmolSystem([fixed_proteins; lipids; solvent];    output = "exosome.cif",    tolerance = 2.0,    unitcell = octahedral_unitcell(Float64, 580.0), # centered at the origin    # check_initial_placement = true, # uncomment to only place the molecules)# Write the output in the shape of the truncated octahedrontriclinic_to_octahedral(system)packmol(system)